Adventures in Reading

Lambda Challenge: The Practical Heart by Allan Gurganus

For the Lambda Challenge: Allan Gurganus’ The Practical Heart is a collection of four novellas that won a Lambda Award for Gay Men’s Fiction in 2001. Fortunately, I had access to a statewide search of university libraries or I would never have been able to find this book [1]. All of the novellas occur or incorporate the fictional city of Falls, North Carolina.

The first novella “The Practical Heart” is a brilliant duel tale of Muriel who led a difficult life and either had her portrait painted by John Singer Sargent… or didn’t. The two stories within the novella were marvelous explorations of class, relationship, age, and sexuality. After finishing it I was decided it was the best in the collection. The second novella “Preservation News” explores the life of a man, Tad, post-mortem through an article he wrote and editor’s comments following it. Tad spent his life saving the decaying and decrepit mansions of the south, and his story is as much told from the editor as the architecture and history of the houses. I read this and revised my opinion: No, this had to be the best story.

The final two novellas in the collection “He’s One, Too” and “Saint Monster” are both told from the perspective of a boy growing into adulthood. Both novellas are explorations of the Other, the outsider, the unwanted, the unaccepted, the inappropriate. Told from the additional perspectives of the white, middle, and suburban class, the reader watches these young boys idolize and love an adult man. While I did not find these two to be nearly as contagious as the first two novellas, they are the two pieces that left me thinking and reconsidering the most.

I loved, loved, loved this collection. Gurganus has a wonderful narrative voice that individualizes the characters and story. I felt that each story was written by an entirely different author, but still manages to flow and interweave into each other. As a writer, Gurganus has a gentle touch and maneuvers well between emotional extremes without (or rarely) overdoing it.

[1] Well, without purchasing it and I’m a bit cash poor these days.

Conclusion: Returned to the library.


It’s too bad the book is difficult to get a hold of. It really sounds like a great one.

Comment by Nymeth

Nymeth: I was rather surprised at how difficult it was to locate, but it was well worth the effort.

Comment by bookchronicle

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: